PostgreSQL vs MySQL: Choosing the Right Open-Source Database
PostgreSQL and MySQL are the two most popular open-source relational databases. PostgreSQL leads in features and data integrity; MySQL in simplicity and read performance.
// Table of Contents
Quick Overview
PostgreSQL
PostgreSQL is an advanced object-relational database known for standards compliance, extensibility, and powerful features like JSONB, full-text search, and advanced indexing. The preferred database for Python backends.
MySQL
MySQL is the world's most popular open-source database, known for ease of use, fast read performance, and massive adoption. Widely used in LAMP stacks, WordPress, and many web applications.
Feature Comparison
PostgreSQL is significantly more feature-rich. It supports JSONB for document storage, arrays, range types, full-text search, custom types, table inheritance, and advanced indexing (GIN, GiST, BRIN). It also supports CTEs (Common Table Expressions), window functions, and lateral joins more completely.
MySQL has improved significantly with version 8.0, adding CTEs, window functions, and JSON support. However, its JSON implementation is less performant than PostgreSQL's JSONB, and it lacks many of PostgreSQL's advanced features.
Performance
MySQL historically excelled at simple read-heavy workloads due to its simpler query planner and storage engine options (InnoDB for transactions, MyISAM for reads). For basic CRUD operations, MySQL can be slightly faster.
PostgreSQL performs better on complex queries, large datasets, and write-heavy workloads. Its advanced query planner handles complex joins and subqueries more efficiently. With proper indexing, PostgreSQL matches or exceeds MySQL for most workloads.
Python Integration
PostgreSQL has better Python support:
- asyncpg: The fastest PostgreSQL driver, designed for async Python
- Django: First-class PostgreSQL support with specific field types (ArrayField, JSONField, HStoreField)
- SQLAlchemy: Excellent PostgreSQL dialect with all features supported
- psycopg3: Modern async-capable driver
MySQL Python support is adequate but less integrated. aiomysql provides async support, and mysqlclient is the standard driver. Django's MySQL backend supports fewer advanced features than its PostgreSQL backend.
Feature Comparison Table
| Feature | PostgreSQL | MySQL |
|---|---|---|
| JSONB Support | Excellent (indexed, queryable) | Basic (JSON type) |
| Full-Text Search | Built-in (advanced) | Basic (FULLTEXT index) |
| Array Types | Yes (native) | No |
| ACID Compliance | Full | Full (InnoDB) |
| Replication | Streaming + Logical | Binary log + Group |
| Partitioning | Declarative (native) | Range, List, Hash |
| License | PostgreSQL License (permissive) | GPL v2 |
| Python Async Driver | asyncpg (excellent) | aiomysql (adequate) |
| Cloud Options | Aurora, Cloud SQL, Supabase | Aurora, Cloud SQL, PlanetScale |
| Community | Growing rapidly | Massive (most used DB) |
Verdict: Which Should You Choose?
Choose PostgreSQL if:
- You need advanced features (JSONB, arrays, full-text search)
- Data integrity and SQL standards compliance matter
- You're building a Python backend (better async drivers and ORM support)
- You need complex queries with window functions and CTEs
- You want extensibility (custom types, functions, indexes)
Choose MySQL if:
- You need maximum compatibility with existing tools and hosting
- Simple read-heavy workloads are your primary use case
- You're working with WordPress or LAMP stack applications
- Your team has deep MySQL expertise
- You need multi-master replication (MySQL Group Replication)
Frequently Asked Questions
Is PostgreSQL harder to learn than MySQL?
For basic usage, they're equally easy. PostgreSQL has more features to discover, but you don't need them all immediately. The biggest learning curve difference is PostgreSQL's stricter SQL compliance - it catches errors that MySQL silently ignores, which is actually a benefit.
Need expert backend development?
I build scalable Python APIs and backend systems. Let's discuss your project.
Get in Touch